Friday, 29 April 2011

Apartheid was propped up by first-past-the-post elections

I voted a number of times in South Africa in the aprtheid era including, and especially, the last three or four elections before the fall of apartheid. Even allowing for the fact that only whites had the vote, I was painfully aware that in the last few elections less than 50% of (white) voters were maintaining the apartheid government in power. The reason for this was a gerrymandering of electoral districts that was enabled by a first-past-the-post system of voting. Voting districts with mainly opposition voters, largely in the cities, had electorate numbers close to the upper limit allowed. Those supporting the regime, mainly in rural areas, had fewer voters, close to the lower limits required. The first-past-the-post system ensured we had "stable," majority government elected year after year by a minority of voters. It was no accident, but a very deliberate decision that was made, to conduct the first democratic elections in South Africa using a system of proportional representation.

The big fear that many Canadians have expressed over proportional representation is the "instability" of minority government or, horror of horrors, a "coalition". Quite honestly, I have to ask which is worse, minority or coalition government on the one hand or a democratically unrepresentative, winner takes all, government that often as not results in two parties with not dissimilar vote counts having a vastly different number of seats in parliament as illustrated in Canada by the Bloc Québécois and the Green Party after the last election? Why should somebody whom 63% of voters have voted against be the one to represent them because the vote was split 37-33-17-13? Why should smaller parties be made to feel guilty for "splitting" the vote on the left or on the right? Is this a democracy or isn't it? I am all for the protection of minorities but why do the democratic rights of the 37% trump the democratic rights of the 63%?

In the riding where I live, the outcome of an election, year after year, is a foregone conclusion. Peter Van Loan will return to Parliament as surely as night follows day. Why should I even bother voting? I know my vote won't count for anything other than to put $2 into the Green Party coffers. On the radio this evening I heard a young immigrant Canadian quoted as saying, "Dad, don't vote. A choice between bad and worse is no choice at all."

I honestly and strongly believe that our winner-takes-all style of voting coupled with our reluctance to see the political parties representing "us" trying to find middle ground with "them" is what has us mired in the point-scoring, negative politicking we have witnessed for the last seven years. It is also hugely responsible for people who do not believe that their vote counts for anything staying away from the ballot boxes.

I found the following list of 82 countries currently using some variation of proportional representation.

Here are a few references:
Wikipedia - Proportional representation

Wikipedia - First-past-the-post voting


Or do your own search: proportional representation pros and cons

Thursday, 28 April 2011

Stand up for your reputation or face the judgement of history

Try doing a search on "The only party that defends the chrysotile industry". It's amazing how many web sites in Canada and the U.S. and abroad are shocked and disgusted at the cavalier, double standards towards asbestos being shown by the past and likely next Prime Minister of Canada, Stephen Harper.

"The only party that defends the chrysotile industry is our party; the Conservative party," Harper said in Asbestos, Que. on Tuesday. Chrysotile is the term for white asbestos that supporters of the asbestos industry prefer.

"Canada is one of a number of exporters of chrysotile and there are many countries in which it is legal who are buyers," Harper said.

"This government will not put Canadian industry in a position where it is discriminated against in a market where sale is permitted."

One would think that Stephen Harper would take his statement to its logical conclusion and seek to legalise again the use and sale of asbestos in Canada; after all, wouldn't that help the economy and create jobs? But no, "We have no plans to do that." On the contrary, work will continue on the stripping of asbestos from parliamentary and government buildings and residences in Ottawa. Why? Because asbestos is a known carcinogen.

Any Conservatives who do not wish to be tarred with this brush of dishonest, double standards need to speak up now - and loudly. Stand up for your reputation or face the judgement of history.

Wednesday, 27 April 2011

Easter Sunday in Peterborough

Everyone except Stephen, who is in South Africa for the wedding of his friend Sean McKenna, got together in Peterborough for dinner and a walk to the lake on Easter Sunday.



Mark cooked an amazing beef roast, assisted by Sean after we arrived. Claire, who is very used to my singing to her while I walk around with her, was decidedly ambivalent about my doing the same with Jonty.

Claire was also very intrigued with the real, live ducks swimming in the lake since she thought she already knew everything about ducks from her story books.
The Uncles

Looking very spiff in my tux (bow-tie hidden)

Monday, 25 April 2011

Mental Illness, Healthcare and the Economy - the $50 billion elephant in the room that nobody's talking about

The federal election campaign has been short on policy discussions, but there’s one issue that needs national attention immediately. It’s a problem that’s having a grave impact on our society and our economy; the problem that is affecting 1 in 5 Canadians — mental illness and addiction.


Mental illness touches all of us at some point in our life. No economic action plan is complete without a focus on the illness that is now the number one cause of workplace disability in Canada. It costs our Canadian economy over $50 billion annually.


Mental health claims have overtaken cardiovascular disease as the fastest growing category of disability costs in Canada. Every day, half a million Canadians are absent from work due to a mental illness or addiction. This is a tangible productivity problem, and it doesn’t include “presenteeism,” those showing up for work, but unable to contribute to their full potential.


If it isn’t compelling enough to talk about today’s problem, think of our future workforce. Our children are being affected seriously and frequently. Depression, anxiety and substance misuse in children and teens is a regular media topic.


We hear of lost potential from lives unlived, student suicide occurring at increasing rates in universities across the country. Our academic institutions, preparing the future of Canada, are struggling to grapple with a health problem that’s been a secret for too long.


It’s time for all party leaders to put this issue on the agenda and start improving the mental health of Canadians.

Carol Lambie, President and CEO, Mental Health Centre Penetanguishene
Glenna Raymond, President and CEO, Ontario Shores
George Weber, President and CEO, Royal Ottawa Mental Health Centre
Catherine Zahn, President and CEO, Centre for Addiction and Mental Health

The above letter was published in today's Toronto Star under the heading, Put mental illness on election agenda

Friday, 22 April 2011

The Holy Thursday Foot Washing - Is the point being lost because of legalism?

It is ironic that commemorating the setting for Jesus' new commandment of love has become an occasion of hurt and division in the Catholic Church.

My wife and daughter complained to me after the Holy Thursday service that there were no women selected for the foot washing. What could I say? All I could do was defend our local clergy and say that their hands are tied because the rubrics, the little red instructions in the missal, talk about selecting men. OK, they said. Then why are nearly all of the men selected old or middle aged white men? Why was there nobody there that youth or young adults could relate to? Other than our fiend Eric, why were there no people of colour? Good questions. I don't know why. Why?

For pastoral considerations the foot washing is optional at this service at the priest's discretion. I have always loved it but I think it is coming under siege - with justification. This is not the first time I have heard these objections. Ingrid's and Judith's remonstrations were pretty meek and mild compared to some of the charges that I have heard from some very impassioned and hurting women. There are many who see this as yet another point where women are made to feel like second class citizens in the Catholic church. I foresee that as the groundswell of antagonism towards the "men only" rule keeps growing, and grow it will, that this will become a point of division in the Church with many women, especially young women and their partners, opting not to go to mass on Holy Thursday, and many priests opting to leave the Mandatum, the foot washing, out of the Holy Thursday liturgy if it is going to cause such pain and division in their congregations.